John Johnson b. 1675 married Elizabeth Lucretia Massie first in 1698. They had children, including my gsgrandfather Benjamin Johnson. Lucretia died in 1711, and John married her sister Sarah Penelope Massie in 1712. Lucretia &amp; Sarahs parents were Peter Massie and Penelope Ashley Cooper. The rumor is this Penelope is the Penelope Ashley Cooper, the illegitimate daughter of Anthony Ashley Cooper of Lord Shaftesbury. There is a question of whether Sara Penelope Massie was married to John or his brother, William.