 structural integrity in water feature construction by cla allgood asla pondkeeper july august 2007 when asked to write about the ldquo strucutal integrity rdquo of ponds i first want to post a disclaimer i am a landscape architect not a structural engineer this is my usual admission i only know enough to be dangerous this i have a healthy respect for structural engineers this article is not going to be the holy grail on pond construction but rather a general discussion on how water feature contractors and pond builders can relate to the concept of structural integrity hopefully this article will at least stir some thought and conversation one definition for ldquo structural integrity rdquo is ldquo structural integrity is a measure of the quality of construction and the ability of the structure to function as require rdquo basically number one ndash does it perform as it was intended to perform number two ndash does it hold up against the forces it was intended to number three ndash will it work for as long as it is supposed to work every component has a structural integrity requirement and the combined effectiveness of these components also has a structural integrity requirement a chain is only as stron as its weakest link obviously we are glad there are professionals who have the big picture when it comes to buildings cars bridges and airplanes to name a few but for the little parts we need to really appreciate and hope that the guy that picked the bolt for the brake pedal in our car knew structurally what he was doing or was he guessing or did he randomly just pick a bold that had a manufacture rsquo s quip on the box that it was ldquo the bolt for all your needs rdquo yikes the point is that for a water feature or pond to have structural integrity each component has to be evaluated in regards to how it is going to be used there are organizations that help with this information astm international originally known as the american society for testing and materials astm was formed over a century ago when engineers and scientists got together to address frequent rail breaks in the growing railroad business their work led to standardization on the steel used in rail construction this organization has gone from giving guidelines on steel to more complicated scenarios likewhat should be the standard of preparation for a hospital to function in different disasters i bet the folks at the astm could help with establishing the standards for fishpond construction once on a landscape project i hired a structural engineer to help me with some post and beam wood construction issues the structure was going to be open and was going to have wind loads he looked at his charts and sized the footings the spacing of the post and the size of the post the project would need i asked him who came up with a chart calculating how wind would affect a structure like this he replied that most of the research was carried out at the direction of an outdoor advertising association then he showed me a picture of a large wood roller coaster he had designed using the same data it is a little spooky to know that the data the outdoor advertising association came up with is also being used for designing roller coasters but someone had to do the legwork i think what always impressed me was that the statistics for that type of construction was not originated by a college professor looking for a math challenge rather the post and wind load standards were instigated by a business concern that had real needs for the information because they wanted to reduce the chance for failure thus promoting structural integrity why because structural integrity is good for every business in the industry the pond industry in my opinion is just getting underway in getting sophisticated enough to organize and or research the metrics which will allow for more ponds being built with successful structural integrity ponds can fail in many methods such as failure of waterproofing failure of filter system pump failure failure of rock structure etc this is to be expected from an industry that not too long ago was not an industry it did not have any real manufacturing but was rather a collection of hobbyists using homemade solutions often times we resort to testimonials from others manufacturers suggestions bless their hearts but they can be optimistic or data generated by other industries while these are all valuable the pond industry is certainly ready to compile more accurate specifications while most associations in the pond industry seemed caught up in giving certificates in construction there is little being done to standardize the information regarding components that make up a pond one should also understand what constitutes structural integrity can and should change from pond to pond this does make things a little more confusing what works for one scenario may not have integrity for another let s go over the definition again structural integrity is a measure of the quality of construction and the ability of the structure to function as required the first responsibility of building with structural integrity rests with the designer this person must define what is required how is it supposed to perform and what forces will be working against it if you cannot define these issues up front in the design stage you cannot aim towards structural integrity in a koi pond this could be the pond has to keep this many pounds of koi fish alive be outside in the maine winter and last 10 years without any repair other than pump light and media replacement because of high water table the criteria includes the pond never being completely drained the owner has 30 labrador dogs now you can define the forces that are working against a successful pond there will certainly be fish waste there will be severe freezing and there will be the dogs and the need to have a bottom that is cleanable while under water so right off the bat it is easy to tell that the pond construction standard that worked for a goldfish pond in a sunroom in florida may not be sufficient and could lead to failure for this pond in maine yet both ponds could have appropriate structural integrity if they met their original design criteria the standards for the components we usemay be available but our businesses need them in terms that we like to use for instance for a paint to say that it meets the minimum level of inter gelatinous anti carbons established by the usda or whatever high brow lingo a chemist may use is not as important to me as a comment that says fish safe and by definition you cannot build a fishpond that qualifies as having good structural integrity if its components kill fish water proofing failure is one of the big visible structural integrity failures on which people focus today s flexible membrane liners have made many pond builders think that structural integrity is a nonissue i am a big fan of flexible liners when my company first started building water features in the mid 1980s we used concrete reinforced with rebar waterproofed with plaster the standard practice of the day when we first were exposed to pvc liners we felt sure that they were shabby construction and probably the work of the devil ultimately we had a client that demanded we use pvc liner covered with concrete as the method of construction we eventually used this method a lot over the next 15 years many of the ponds we built with this technique have needed minimum service while the pools we had built at the same time using concrete steel plaster construction have had to undergo major renovation so we have a lot of good testimonial and firsthand experience with flexible liners but is liner always the best way to build a water feature no can you say that the swimming pools have less structural integrity no the swimming pools had different performance requirements we wanted a surface that was barefoot friendly yet was not slick thus plaster was chosen and since the plaster on the pools lasted as long as the client expected the pools had appropriate structural integrity to this day we rely on different types of construction the latest liners are ultraviolet resistant so now you don t even have to protect them from the sun however if you have forces around your pond like labradors kids with sharp sticks or a probability of public vandalism protecting the liner would be adding structural integrity to the predictable forces by overestimating the forces your pond may need to deal with you are increasing your margin for structural integrity and success every component and every mechanical system associated with ponds have its own structural integrity value for us that also includes the structural integrity value of installing the component we once worked with a pond product that was fine once it was installed but it was subject to failure during installation we gave this low marks on the structural integrity scale because part of how it was supposed to perform included the actual performance of installation finally you cannot talk about structural integrity without talking about safety ponds are built typically with a design requirement of helping people or delighting people recently i have read about individuals that have died from consuming too many bottles of water in a short period of time everything can be dangerous if used incorrectly however we should always strive for making sure our structures and components are especially strong relative to the safety of the public in conclusion structural integrity is a very important condition for a pond or water feature to have it starts with identifying what is the goal of the structure what forces will be working against it and what is the desired life of the structure it applies to the components individually how they are installed and how they work together as a system as an industry we need to continue to share common definitions deficiencies and solutions we should promote the need for independent testing only by working together to provide the consumer with successful projects accurate descriptions and appropriate solutions can we stay competitive with the other industries that are competing for the consumers smiles and hard earned dollars about the author cla allgood and janet allgood own wakoola water gardens  wwwwakoolacom  cla is a founding member of the national association of pond professionals he is a landscape architect and owner of allgood outdoors  wwwallgoodoutdoorscom  and a member of the american society of landscape architects how about an aboveground pool  hi cla we have an aboveground pool in our backyard and i m planning to give it a fix you have mentioned about plaster pool i wonder if its applicable for our pool nfl jerseys so first lawrence taylor jersey of all put darren mcfadden jersey up christmas lights or hanukah lights if that s your preference she taught little francesca or sam bradford jersey cecchina as she was called because she was sidney rice jersey so lawrence timmons jerseys delicate everything she knew if he relies bo jackson jersey upon it and jay cutler jersey it contains untruths which are believed you could be in big trouble apart from just losing jason campbell jersey the job if you are found out all you need to do is to log on terry bradshaw jersey to his official website at john mellencamp tour dates online and everything that you dustin keller jersey need to know about his next concerts should be james harrison jerseys found onlineif your joe namath jersey car clay matthews jersey is going to be used in your business and not chad ocho cinco jersey just for visiting customers michael vick jersey and clients then a brian dawkins jersey commercial auto liability policy may make sense there buster posey jersey are many nuances that you brian urlacher jersey may have to custom jets jersey know about and practice diligently before being able lynn swann jerseys to nnamdi asomugha jersey master charles woodson jersey this style of dancingso first demarcus ware jersey of all put up christmas lights mike wallace jersey  or aaron rodgers jersey hanukah lights if that s your preference canon has recently introduced new models to its imageprograf series including ziggy hood jerseys the ipf6350 ipf6300 jerome bettis jersey andipf8300 marcus allen jersey that maurkice pouncey jerseys is capable of producing prints measuring up to 44 inches wide walking has tony romo jersey long been known for it s calming effects on jim plunkett jersey the mind and spirit one of the important troy polamalu jerseys things is the jason witten jersey amount of security your fences raiders jerseys need to peyton manning jersey provide there is a wealth of legal authority that promoting academic qualifications over what custom steelers jersey you have can be an actionable rolando mcclain jersey misrepresentationhave you been asked to play santa at brandon marshall jersey the office school party do you have the chance to earn some kevin greene jerseys extra cash by being a department store santa  jared allen jersey don t turn this down it does brandon jacobs jersey not mean that you wholesale nfl jerseys will be hopelessly overdressed and running the risk of overheating by dressing up in thick furtrimmed outfits when the thermometer is reading 30c joe greene jerseys or morepart of the advantage of the independent shop zach miller jersey is that they do not have to generate profit and cover costs in order mark sanchez jersey to subsidize business departments as typically darrelle revis jersey seen franco harris jerseys in new car shonn greene jersey dealershipsthe legal advice ken stabler jersey is therefore clearftentimes in the haste and excitement of getting your small business up donovan mcnabb jersey and running one important eli manning jersey aspect is forgotten or neglected company s who install george blanda jersey security fences will have a range of varying levels of fences that will be suitable to cheap authentic jersey your needs and will louis murphy jersey be able to michael crabtree jersey help you make the right rod woodson jerseys decisionthe story of mother cabrini as she has been called throughout the twentieth century is very simple one james farrior jerseys of the important things is the amount of security your fences need to provide this is important if you are wholesale jerseys planning to use this dance style jack lambert jersey to create an interesting rocky bleier jerseys dance lamarr woodley jerseys routine for yourselffor example  custom raiders jersey if a customer nick mangold jersey trips hines ward jerseys over an electrical cord and breaks an ankle while visiting your business that insurance darren mcfadden jersey is there rashard mendenhall jersey to protect your business this way it is very mike webster jerseys easy for you to check john santonio holmes jersey mellencamps next concert gig and book the ladainian tomlinson jersey tickets online right at jets jerseys the same site aside from the convenience booking right at the website assures you wholesale mlb jerseys that howie long jersey you will always jimmy clausen jersey be brett favre jersey getting real tickets at all troy polamalu jersey timespart of jerome bettis jerseys the advantage of the independent shop braylon edwards jersey is that they do not have tim brown jersey to generate richard seymour jersey profit and cover costs in order mark sanchez jersey to subsidize business departments as typically seen in new car dealershipso this is your first real british ben roethlisberger jerseys christmas percy harvin jersey away walter payton jersey from home  nfl jerseys independents will typically mark sanchez jersey charge a lower rate from the original factory dealer with independent shops they tim brown jersey are more likely to brandon jacobs jersey fix the rocky bleier jerseys problem without resorting to ordering aaron rodgers jersey as many new parts this way it is very easy for you to check john mellencamps next concert joe greene jerseys gig and book the tickets online  michael vick jersey right at the same site aside from darren mcfadden jersey the convenience  jim plunkett jersey booking right at the website assures you that you will always be getting real tickets at bo jackson jersey all times by making the commitment to walk on a daily basis you will be eli manning jersey tapping brian dawkins jersey into an amazing peyton manning jersey source joe namath jersey of wholesale mlb jerseys power much bigger than you lawrence timmons jerseys realize after you start your daily mike wallace jersey walking habit you ll be happily flabbergasted with the wonderful benefits that will start showing up in your lifeso what exactly do you need to do to begin an exercise program based on ben roethlisberger jerseys walking a pair of shoes some sorts and a tshirt  custom steelers jersey perhaps a hat if you live in a particularly james harrison jerseys sunny climate and you are michael crabtree jersey all set percy harvin jersey this lamarr woodley jerseys will not be christmas like you remembered it from a child independent shops can provide equal if not better quality of work brian urlacher jersey as compared to factory shops cricket christmas is the season for experiencing a bit of good kevin greene jerseys old fashioned culture clash that insurance comes into play if a worker is injured on the job if you sam bradford jersey lied on your cv maurkice pouncey jerseys this could very well be jerome bettis jersey considered santonio holmes jersey gross misconduct brandon marshall jersey sufficient to zach miller jersey justify a dismissalyour memories of christmas dinner probably involve barbecues beaches pavlova nick mangold jersey  topped with passionfruit kiwifruit or donovan mcnabb jersey strawberries but we lynn swann jerseys won t get george blanda jersey into the rolando mcclain jersey great mike webster jerseys pavlova jay cutler jersey debate here the first ziggy hood jerseys of the new potatoes berryfruit in season salads and making the most of a home vegetable garden jason witten jersey in full production troy polamalu jerseys another kind of small business insurance that is available to protect your chad ocho cinco jersey business is general liability insuranceyou ll find the dustin keller jersey lucia tony romo jersey ex system in canon s newest range of large format printers this will not only help you become a better hip hop marcus allen jersey dancer but also would help franco harris jerseys you integrate your cheap authentic jersey own routine within the overall parameters of hip hop dance styles when you buster posey jersey perform yes  braylon edwards jersey you read that rightcanon s large format printers for professional walter payton jersey printers start at 17 inches and go all the way up to 60 inches wide this is why it is essential that you richard seymour jersey sign up for hip hop dance lessons so that you can dazzle your family and friends the next time raiders jerseys you are at a party sidney rice jersey with them that aspect is nnamdi asomugha jersey insurance products that serve custom raiders jersey to protect your business however it jerome bettis jerseys is jared allen jersey an essential part of any insurance packageanother kind of insurance is business wholesale jerseys interruption ladainian tomlinson jersey insurance terry bradshaw jersey there are a rashard mendenhall jersey wide range of options available such as keypad entry closed circuit television timing systems swipe cards proximity cards and key switches so having the right level of access lawrence taylor jersey is very importantpart troy polamalu jersey of howie long jersey the advantage louis murphy jersey of jason campbell jersey the independent wholesale nfl jerseys shop is that they do not have to generate profit and jack lambert jersey cover ken stabler jersey costs hines ward jerseys in order to subsidize business departments as typically seen in new car dealerships in cases where cars are still under the manufacturer brett favre jersey warranty parts are replaced on james farrior jerseys a larger number of claims in the eyes of the law this could well be obtaining a financial advantage being what you custom jets jersey are going to charles woodson jersey get darren mcfadden jersey paid by deception cricket christmas is darrelle revis jersey the season for experiencing a jets jerseys bit of good old fashioned culture clashtoday getting the latest on news on john mellencamp concerts can shonn greene jersey easily be done over the internet today he is now considered mark sanchez jersey as one of the most sought after performers in the country holding concert tours all around jimmy clausen jersey the rod woodson jerseys united clay matthews jersey states  demarcus ware jersey 