Setlist.fm has been corrected and James B's link added.

If his had been up on archive.org when the original setlist.fm post was made, the link would have also been included in the first comment (it isn't) and the discrepancy would have been questioned before the setlist was posted. 
There were a shitton of setlists scoured from the two old fan sites, from archive.org, and from anywhere else that was pointed to in a fan post, when GPN's setlist.fm was started up during the change over to the current gracepotter.com in June of 2010. 
Did I copy/paste when possible - absolutely. Did I take the time to listen to every set - no. I was spending every free minute finding and carrying the information over. There were a lot of shorthand things to figure out in the fan posts as it was, it would have taken even longer to verify every taper list. Usually tapers know what they are posting or there are comments left in the review section if there are problems. <i>(There still wasn't one for the Gumbo Moon error btw - I'll add it)</i> Is it possible that there are other errors? Hell yes .. feel free to correct/let me know if anyone finds one. 

Eric, I didn't see your comment in 2010 or I would have asked then. If you notice discrepancies in the future, please let me know, or post them in a comment / edit directly on setlist.fm yourself.  I have it set up to get emails for new comments/edits.  I don't always read everything posted on the forum or even in here. (sorry KC)