Congratulations KC ! .. to misquote Margaret Mead - never doubt that a small group of dedicated people can change the world...
I'm completely thrilled for all you 'posse' folks there last night. :D 
Especially for Tedheadone ..who probably has better stats than what follows ...

Pain to do this w/phone, but now that am on the pc .. as always remember stats on Setlist.fm are not complete but here's what it's got for Belladonna: 
42 entries from May 28, 2006 to January, 2008 
27 from 5/28/06 to 12/31/06
12 from 3/9/07 to 9/12/07
3 in January 2008
last shows:
The Parish, New Orleans, LA, USA on January 22, 2008
Smith's Olde Bar, Atlanta, GA, USA on January 19, 2008
Workplay Theater, Birmingham, AL, USA on January 17, 2008 
NoHo shows:
Pearl Street, Northampton, MA, USA on September 8, 2007 
Iron Horse Music Hall, Northampton, MA, USA on September 20, 2006  

http://www.setlist.fm/stats/grace-potter-and-the-nocturnals-53d77b6d.html  .. click Song to alpha sort, then click the song title for drop down of shows. 

I just have to make a pitch here .. this is a perfect example of why getting setlists matters .. and yes, I know it's an annoyance to do - I've done it every time I can get to a show .. but now that phones are smart - setting up a draft message and adding to it takes seconds .. and the results add to the band's history.  
[/soapbox]