Pulp Fiction - 
Grace as Mia / Uma Thurman (quote: "I wanna dance, I wanna win, I want that trophy -  So dance good!") Take the Maude Lebowski wig, paint it black.
Matt as Jules / Sam Jax (Ezekiel - I will strike down upon you with great vengeance...) Maybe a stretch, but has experience with faux facial hair.
Benny as Lance the dealer / Eric Stoltz - (Mi casa su casa or Prank Caller! Prank Caller!) rockin the same bathrobe as the Dude.
Scott as Vince / Travolta (I don't think Buddy Holly's much of a waiter...) Rumored to have the "Batman dance" down pat.
Cat as Honey Bunny / Amanda Plummer (Any of you f'ing prix move and I'll execute every m-f'ing last one of you)  lured back with the blessing to shout this out loud and often during the course of the night. In a fantasy world babe, you're always included.
K Chesney won't be brought out as the Gimp, but instead plays a cameo  as Butch / Bruce Willis. lose the hat and 'nuff said. (Zed's dead baby, Zed's dead.)

And the music - plenty of surf music for the guitar aficionados , steller covers of "Let's Stay Together" and "You Never Can Tell," "You'll be a Woman Soon," and finally the long awaited debut of Dusty Springfield's "Son of a Preacher Man."

great night ending with foot massages and Royales with cheeses for everyone.