No Gumbo Moon on this Setlist
http://archive.org/details/gpn2010-06-12.pmd661.cd2go.flac24

Gumbo Moon IS on this setlist
http://www.setlist.fm/setlist/grace-potter-and-the-nocturnals/2010/webster-hall-new-york-ny-53d4672d.html

I just listened to the recording and there is NO Gumbo Moon there - ergo - Setlist.FM is wrong

http://www.setlist.fm/setlist/grace-potter-and-the-nocturnals/2008/webster-hall-new-york-ny-13d41569.html

Now, this Webster Hall show has a better story
http://www.setlist.fm/setlist/grace-potter-and-the-nocturnals/2008/webster-hall-new-york-ny-13d41569.html

"I have a question, do you like cheese" 
http://www.thisissomewhere.com/2008/12/12/webster-hall-nyc-live-show/

Grace asked me if her "tits looked nice in this dress" and we played pool across the street afterwards. #IAmNotMakingThisUp #TheGoodOldDays