how about we review the reviews ? (politely of course)
background info was okay ... light on actual song/album comments 
was curious so randomly checked some of his other reviews . . he doesn't consistently use stars, in fact most of what I happened to check weren't ranked in anyway 
but did find Hendrix -"Valley's of Neptune" - 4,  Cohen - "Live in London" (wrote mostly about the concert he went to )- 4.5 . . not bad company to be in with a 3.5