Okay. I am gonna make a guess here and it's nothing more then a guess!

We all thought this song was written by Grace  for One Tree Hill to be sung by her and Bethany whatsherface.

However; perhaps the drum head with the band/owl logo is the key. After TIS came out, the bass drum went to the album visual. And later this last year it went plain, the owl logo has not re-appeared.

Could it be...is it possible that this was a song that was born at the same time as "Mastermind" and "Mr Columbus" but did not make it onto the album?  AHA!!  Inquiring minds want to know...

P.S. The butler did it in the library with a candlestick.