I feel like I should comment here, but I'm really not sure what to say.  It's oddly flattering that my experiment has garnered so much attention, and I honestly feel like I'm doing a respectable job not taking sides.  Maybe imitation is the sincerest form of flattery?   I dunno ... 

To paraphrase an old clothing store up here in Boston, "And educated consumer is the best customer."  
Best of luck ... 

--Scott
www.scottfeldman.net