Well i read your whole review:) Well done. Ive seen the film 5 times, and i still enjoyed it lots the fifth time  no boredom/movie fatigue at all( so i really should see it again), but is hard to know how it compares exactly because it is big 3d movie experience &amp; so much to take in. I still noticed new things 5th time also &amp; having diff. experiences with diff. parts. The ending finale of the sea serpent battle etc is perfectly judged it seems to me, as was the ending finales of LW&amp;W, where as a part of PCs was slightly misjudged to me. Once use to it, the green mist is great &amp; its initial introduction is only bit that could have benefited from a abit more developed &amp; less arbitrary introduction, &amp; also being played up abit more as being terrifying to the lone Island culture. The lone island escapade is only bit of film that feels slightly less of the films overall momentum &amp; dramatic story to me, &amp; its when the echoes of the book are strongest particularly after short battle, that the film gets back to its Narnian VOTDT adventure that it builds on up from there in. Over all the actings different, not better or worse i think from previous two, and i thought Ben Barnes was well suited to Caspian in PC at the time, and that Georgies Lucy in PC is really good to watch in the acting for just how well its done (Skandars Edmund maybe like that for me with this film &amp; that character opening up) but now that i think about it.. the overall acting in PC was great, the telmarines were awesome too. VOTDT is diff. creative movie, time, diff. story, diff character arcs that came about diff. way &amp; what suits one not suit the other etc but way acting done is diff facet to enjoy with the characters being main thing &amp; this remains a success for VOTDT to me.