You claim this happend in all these other instances (like strat and scholo) which only being 5 man I guess I kinda miss the point there.  Is this from people stil in the guild?  I remember Warmaki/Fuzzynips I guess...

I don't know.  I get what you're saying Mase and agree on one hand.  If someone is way undergeared then they should probably work on their gear in whatever way they can so they aren't being pulled through and taking gear from people who have been there, have done their share of the work, paying a good share of repair bills and put in the time so to speak.  

On the other hand, if I decide taht I want to bring Temblor (my alt) cause 4 hours of my life on a couple of consecutive nights wouldn't net my hunter much at all I don't want to feel like the loot chance is zero.  Then again I don't want to have a guild where we have to claim our mains, alts and then get them licensed by the guild every time we feel like changing.  That doesn't seem like us either.

I don't think we're headed down that road that people seem stressed about where someone is taking all the loot but I suppose it's a good idea to talk it out before we get into the situation to cut down on the drama.