I think there is something to be said about keeping somethings unchanged, yet there is also a benefit in making newer people feel like they have a greater since of belonging.  For me, i have no emotional attachment to the tabor.  I wouldn't care if it was bright pink with a big boner on it, I would still display it with pride, as it is our tabor.  

However if it makes for a bunch of fun to have people run with a type of contest, i think it sounds fun.  It might be something we could do on a bi-monthly basis, so that everyone has a shot at a creative design.  Or it could be a setup to signify change in the guild.  For example the current tabor could signify where we came from.  a new one would stand for who we are now and are accomplishments.  and there may be a new one down the road that shows what we accomplish once we are a lvl 70 guild.  

Since many people who were around at the beginning are no longer with us, why not have one that represents the current core?  But if you all are really tied to the current one, i really don't care, like i said I'm not that emotional about it, it is a very minor issue to discuss, nothing I would like to see baloon into an isssue.