personnaly I'm a little taken back.  I understand your troubles with some players, frankly everyone has their someone in the group they would rather not run with whom they find annoying, but the question is what are you doing about it.  I don't want to sound pompous or condesending, but what are you doing about it? Sure you can quit and hope you dont find other annoyin gplayers elsewhere, or you can challenge those in guild talk to mind their manners, hold private conversations in private, and to continue to press for officer decisions on policey.  Tell me if i'm wrong, and I may be, I really don't know you well enough but it seem a lot like someone who didn't get his way soon enough (kicking kana, jtg) so he is quitting.  similarly to the kid in the playground that wanted his rules in football, or he is taking his ball and going home.  

Dont get me wrong, I too support kicking those two out, I voted to, but not for their specific actions, or annoyances in guild chat, but because they are just not a good fit fo rthe team.  Their play sucks, they are annoying, they don't follow instructions, and they dont contribute to anyone in the guild. (they run for themselves, and look for help for them, not offering for others)  

But before I will settle for abandoning FSE, I would like to try to come up with a code of conduct, policy for kicking, and better questions on the app.  they currently dont tell you anything about the personality of the applicant, just minor details about their character that mean nothing.   Questions like: explain why or why not you believe yoko destroyed the beattles?  What ever happened to Tang? and From what movie is &quot;i'll call him a chicken fucker&quot; from?

So in closing, I don't think you should abandon FSE before a valiant effort has been put forth to change it for the good.  We need to quit the drama, and clean some house, get back to basics, and revise how we intend ot grow.