I like the manifesto.  It makes since to impliment a little structure with the growth of the guild.  My only question of participation is if there is some way of tracking who participated in what activities.  Exp.  a great item drops, two mages need, and one argues they have run more than the other.  Do we just let the roll determine, or is there a place where people log/post activities?  for example, a raid leader logs the members who participated, and in what raid, or is that too much micromanagement?