We're going to have a huge difference of opinion like we always do on this.  I think we've all passed things to people and we've all probably rolled on stuff that would have been a bigger upgrade to someone else than it was to our character.  I don't feel as strongly as you do on this but I'm not going to argue it.  If we're going to be about making the guild the best we can, then why even random roll, and just give it out utilitarian and equitable-like?  Look at who would be upgraded and give to that person.

The other concern though is our guild is pretty fragmented on having a full and consistent group so it seems like anyone who shows up should get a fair shot at something that isn't obnoxiously out of their spec or class.

I'm sure Yoda would have a good quote for us all to bring it all home and set us straight.  I enjoy playing with you guys...I suppose it'd just be best if we vented our frustrations here without a bunch of name calling and hurt feelings if we can and try to find a solution to this instead of being hurt and beating around the bush.  Heh....nevermind.