[quote:1284d59bc9="Baeloc"][quote:1284d59bc9="Temblor"] If we're going to be about making the guild the best we can, then why even random roll, and just give it out utilitarian and equitable-like?  Look at who would be upgraded and give to that person.[/quote:1284d59bc9] Sounds good.  As long as it's not an upgrade for that person's character who they just got to 70 vs someone who has been raiding Kara for a while and that loot finally drops.

[quote:1284d59bc9]The other concern though is our guild is pretty fragmented on having a full and consistent group so it seems like anyone who shows up should get a fair shot at something that isn't obnoxiously out of their spec or class.[/quote:1284d59bc9]  But I dont think that if I bring Cayis I should be rolling on Legacy (a huge upgrade for him) if Jamsheed is in the party.

I just would like to have everyone in the guild look at what they're rolling on for the guild.  There's purples from kara cooling on people's alts that could be used for people in the guild.  Yet those people bring other characters to Kara and take more loot from other people.[/quote:1284d59bc9]

The way I see it, either way we go, (random rolls or the communist &quot;who needs it  most&quot;) if I brought my hunter and Legacy dropped, either he'd have about a 1 in 4 chance at worst if alts and mains rolled on it, or if we did who would it be a bigger upgrade for and we thought it would be a bigger upgrade for Cayis (he certainly needs the gear, have you looked at that guy! :),  if Jamsheed didn't win or receive it, the next time his odds go way up to get it.   And other loot that drops during that run, since we generally don't have people taking 2 purples (unless people are passing on stuff), I would have a better shot at because whoever got legacy would not get to roll on the next huntery piece since they got their tasty treat for the run.

Either way we go, if people follow the &quot;I'm not going to lay claim to multiple pieces this run, even if I COULD spec resto or dps and use it later&quot;  it evens out in the end.  Does anyone else want to weigh in on this so Baeloc and I aren't the two old coots on the porch in rocking chairs rehashing all the same old arguments?