I don't get this idea that if you're an English major, then you cannot NOT love a book. Come on, even if a book is considered a classic, it doesn't mean you have to love it. Everybody likes certain things and hates others. OK, maybe hate is a strong word, but you know what I mean. I really liked Debbie's idea about starting the discussion with your reasons for struggling with the book. It's great! There are so many times when people forget you're entitled to an opinion. Why say you like something just because you're supposed to?