Thanks for the info on the Y'all, pretty interesting.

I looked into your extra copy, and what happened is when you renewed they gave you a new membership number, instead of renewing your old one. So you got 1 issue as a "grace" issue from your old membership, and 1 issue from your new membership number. That's not the way it should have worked, and you might want to call McMillen's and get your old membership number back. If you haven't throw away those poly bags, you'll see above your name one is your old membership, and one is the new.

As to the extra copy, why not give it to a friend or Oliver collector that doesn't get it, and maybe they'll want to join.