Haven't seen "Charlie..." or the Corpse Bride, but count me in as a fan of Big Fish. 
But I also have to agree with Trevor:
"I also think it's time Tim Burton got over whatever fixation he has with his father as this comes through in virtually every film." 

The Nightmare before Christmas would be my favorite Burton film, IF it was directed by Burton. After all this years, I think that Henry Salick was probably better suited for it.