Im glad you started this thread because I think you have a great idea going here. I have one question for you. Does your list only include your pick for the winner in all four categories or does it also include the nominees as well? Anyhow, if were going to debate any winner on this extensive list I think well need to just go with one year at a time. (For the record, I see some great movies and performances herenot to mention a ton of ones I have never seen.)

Im going to start with Best Picture 1995. Your pick is: Before Sunrise
After doing a little research I want to say that 1995 was a great year. Here is a list of the movies I thought were the best:

12 Monkeys
Nixon
Heat
Casino
Leaving Las Vegas
Strange Days
To Die For
Shallow Grave
The Basketball Diaries
The Usual Suspects
Se7en

Ok. I am leaning toward 12 Monkeys, Heat, The Usual Suspects and Se7en. If you put a gun to my head and made me pickI would give the Oscar to12 Monkeys. This was fun. Ill be back to pick another year/category.