I have watched this film. 
I feel like procrastinating a review until I watched it again. 

As of now, I can only say ... 
(i) among the best selling poing has to be Daniel Day Lewis; somehow, Dano pales too much in comparison ... i am just wondering, would there be an actor that would match Daniel? Reason: Dano's role is so interesting that it shouldnt be difficult to garner a supporting role nomination, but he didnt ... 
(ii) the various scenes dealing with religion can be rather "tricky" or even "disturbing" for some people. depending on where you stand, it may even affect your assessment of the film ... but for those who are willing to look beyond, the film does have several interesting themes/messages ... worth discussing ... 
(iii) the soundtrack is rather different 

Humbly ... 
I think there is no clear winner this year ... 
All the 5 films in Oscar (or 7 in Golden Globe) have their pros and some cons ... 
Maybe 2 or 3 deserve more attention ... bet you guess it ... 
Let me contemplate which of the 3 is better ... Atonement? No Country For Old Men? There Will Be Blood?