Nice to see you posting lengthier comments peppajaa. I hope this will happen more often. 

Judgment is also one of my favorite films, and imo one of the best Hollywood made about the second World War.

The script and the direction are great indeed, but you also shouldn't forget the phantastic camerawork, especially during some of the interrogation scenes where it keeps tracking around the character's heads, as if trying to find an entrance into their minds. 

The performances were completely stunning. At first I didn't even recognize Judy Garland! Almost everybody did something different this time around.