I have seen Volver, and unfortunately due to problems noted elsewhere I am not able to give it the time it deserves for a decent review.

In some ways it's like a step backwards for him especially in terms of cast, Penlope Cruz, Carmen Maura & Lola Dueas have all been regular cast members in previous films. 

In terms of story, it's a film that revolves around itself, history repeating between generations though with varying outcomes, I don't think Volver will alter anyones opinion but it is very enjoyable and at times a touch melodramatic. The one thing it does do is make you think the story is going in one direction then switch to another, during one part it looks like it's building up to some form of romance, but that's just left by the wayside. 

The performances are as good as you would expect with such an ensemble and Penlope Cruz holds the attention throughout. There are a couple of beautifully composed scenes and very artistic shots, colour as usual is used to great effect and to be honest it's the sort of film that leaves you wanting more, I was surprised how quickly and easily the 2 hour running time slipped by.

Having read through the previous comments on this thread I must admit that there are some good points raised especially from the detractors, one thing I must say though, I have never seen Almodvar's films as "art-house", to me they are very typically Spanish with everything that entails. I do feel that Volver is somewhat subdued, particularly compared with some of his earlier films, it is lightweight considering several elements of the plotline but it is a well made and at times touching film. 

I give it my recommendation (for what that's worth), it may not convert people to his films but it will hopefully transport you away for a while and will certainly entertain you.

No doubt I'll write more once everything is sorted out with the P.C. and particularly when others have seen the film.

Cheers Trev.