Hehe, I'm also trying to compile this, but from 1895 onwards. My biggest problem though, is that my taste has evolved during the last couple of years, and I'd probably need to rewatch some 3000+ films...
I just hope that my tastes won't have made a similar switch when I have watched a satisfying number of films. But my task actually isn't as difficult as it seems, because I am satisfied with a Top Ten, if it's full of "masterpieces" (imo of course): that means that I could theoretically watch ten films from 1933 next week, and if they bring me to my knees, the year is "done" (of course modifying still takes place with every new film I see). On the other hand I could see one hundred, and still have only 5 worthy of such a high ranking. 
But so far I pretty much know myself and a bit of filmhistory, meaning that my guess on what I'll probably think of a film, even when I haven't seen it yet, is pretty close 70% of the time.