Yes, clever, but does bigpoppa truly think Renoir is the only great director, or does he just have a smart mouth? Surely others are worthy - I would consider Malle, Herzog, Kieslowski etc. great directors. Not always perfect films but unquestionably masters at their best. It's worth remembering that a great director will not always make great films - as far as I'm concerned, the greatest directors will take risks and experiment (not that Renoir doesn't do that...).