Regardless both lists seem a little silly. Not to say I don't like making my own lists, but sometimes it can get a little stale reading someone else's. I've come to prefer the lists that I actually feel I can learn something from. Even though Rosenbaum might be a pompous ass and anybody who wouldn't list Casablanca or The Godfather in their top 1000 reeks of film snobbery, some of his titles have opened my eyes to a far more diverse group of films than most "essential" lists.