Hi Gina, 
We used to live in Passaic for 17 years and I finished in PHS. Small world!
About the cross, I don't have the used cross you've ordered. I only have the new ones at regular price. All my cutters are hand made and sometimes they change the measurements a little but I've never seen them change that much unless you make the changes due to the customers needs or requests. The one we have now is 5.5"  x  4" and the regular price is $6.99. Let me know if you still want it and I can send you a money request for the $3.00 through pay pal.
Best regards and God bless you,
Edith De La Flor